While some may describe Hulu or Netflix as just modern-day streaming services, I’d describe them as portals to the past. With a variety of different shows and movies to choose from, I can always count on finding something that I haven’t seen before (even if they came out 20 years ago).
One might argue that 2000s shows are overrated, but they’d be wrong. The era of “Gossip Girl” and “One Tree Hill” is what Glamour magazine is referring to as “the Golden Age of television” and here’s why:
Rewatching “Gilmore Girls” is a ritual for me every October. Airing from 2000-2007, the show follows the bubbly and eventful lives of Lorelai (Lauren Graham) and Rory Gilmore (Alexis Bledel), a mother-daughter duo living in the fictitious town of Stars Hollow, Connecticut. The small-town charm and energy that the characters bring to each episode make rewatching 6 seasons easy. The quick-paced conversations and never-ending laughs are in my opinion what makes the series so comforting. Shows nowadays lack the same kind of wit and comfort the shows of the 2000s did. Take “Ginny and Georgia”, for example. Although the show has similar themes, the nostalgic masterpiece that is “Gilmore Girls” is not something that can be replicated.
A main issue I have with current shows in comparison to those of the 2000s is their severe lack of dramatization and the constant predictability. However, “The OC” (2003-2007) which starred actors Peter Gallagher and Adam Brody, never fails to have me on the edge of my seat. With the average episode running for about 44 minutes, there’s always plenty of time for scandalous and jaw-dropping storylines. Today, a lot of shows barely reach 30 minutes per episode and have shorter seasons which can sometimes make the plot feel rushed or incomplete.
Further emphasizing the idea that shows today are simply not long enough, I must reference my favorite show of all time, “One Tree Hill” (2003-2012). Each episode is roughly 60 minutes with eight seasons in total. This allows viewers to grow an attachment to the characters and see their character arc in full. Unfortunately, the problem with streaming culture is that oftentimes shows get canceled before even the second season. So then we’re left with one season of a predictable show with 24-minute episodes that more than likely doesn’t star early 2000s heartthrob Chad Michael Murray.
There have been times when remakes of the classic 2000s shows have been attempted, but they’re rarely ever quite as successful. “Gossip Girl” (2007-2012) starring Blake Lively and Leighton Meester, ran for six seasons. Truly ahead of its time as it was incredibly influenced by social media stalking at a time when a lot of the social media apps we use today weren’t even created yet. The glamorous and dramatic lives of the Upper East Side teens had many people drawn into their fantasy world for years. A remake was created in 2021 and though the series had potential, it was canceled earlier this year after only two seasons. As I mentioned earlier, some things just can’t be replicated.
Overall, the shows of the 2000s bring a sense of nostalgia, drama, and wit to the screen that many shows today haven’t been able to master. Whether the plot style of these shows will ever resurface is unclear, but until then, we have our portals to the past at just a click of a button.
Benjamin • Oct 8, 2024 at 3:25 pm
I’ve been feeling this for a few years now. I just can’t find a good show to watch that hooks me like the early 2000’s shows did. I think part of the problem is, as you mentioned, the current shows are not only too short in run time, but also in numbers of episodes. I’m sorry, but after 8-10 short episodes I’m not attached to the characters in the same way. I’m likely gonna forget about them in a couple weeks, let alone by season 2 (if we get one.)
The classic shows had 20-24 episodes that were usually 45 minutes. We had to tune in weekly to see what’s been happening in their lives and in the time in between we could ruminate on the episode and/or talk to our friends about it. A show that has me watching it and talking about it for 24 weeks of the 52 week year is gonna remain in your mind for years to come. A 10 episode show that I binged over a weekend isn’t gonna have that same effect.
I don’t want to get too PC about this, but I HAVE to briefly mention the different approaches in how the classic vs current shows handled topics like LGBTQ+ characters, race/culture, identity, sexual assault, etc. is incomparable. The classics addressed them without fear of offense or pandering to the demands of the public, but rather because the writers felt passionate about sending a message that they felt needed to be heard by at least 1 person who may be watching. They handled it with care and respect. One Tree Hill had SO MANY hard topics addressed, but they didn’t leave you feeling preached at, but rather hopeful that one day things could change for the better, even if not right now. The characters and what they struggled with felt relatable and real and not just placeholders to a fill representation role.
Streaming has also severely hurt tv series. They come out with short seasons with short episodes, but it takes them one and a half to two years to come out with a new season. By then, who’s talking about the show? Not many.
Hopefully we’ll return to a place where TV shows have the same quality and quantity of the early 2000s classics.